Ideas

Opposition prospects 2019 & beyond?

Santosh Desai
[ March 28, 2017 ]
What does the Opposition do now? It has been thoroughly out-thought and outplayed by a combination of charismatic leadership and meticulous on-ground implementation. As Omar Abdullah confessed on Twitter, the Opposition does not have a chance in 2019; perhaps building for 2024 is the only option. The Congress may not, in any real sense last till then and the AAP’s early promise has fizzled out in a tame haze of small-mindedness. If one were...
Read More

Behavioural accountability for politicians

Pankaj Vohra
[ March 28, 2017 ]
It is not for the first time that a Member of Parliament or a politician has been involved in an unpleasantly unpardonable incident. There is sufficient prima facie evidence to proceed against Shiv Sena leader Ravindra Gaikwad, who allegedly repeatedly thrashed an elderly Air India staffer with his sandal after he was allotted an economy category seat on a flight that did not have business class. Air India authorities have filed two FIRs ag...
Read More

Censoring MPs

A.G. Noorani
[ March 26, 2017 ]
Right at the outset, India decided to have a “parliamentary system of constitution, the British type of constitution, with which we are familiar,” as Vallabhbhai Patel said in June 1947. This emulation went to unusual lengths, the British model getting a specific mention in the Indian constitution, which came into effect on Jan 26, 1950. Articles 105(3) and 194(3) of the constitution empower, respectively, parliament and state legislatures...
Read More

Fighting BJP's tsunami

S Nihal Singh
[ March 26, 2017 ]
There is a sub-text to the surprise elevation of the hardline Hindutva icon, Yogi Adityanath, to the post of Chief Minister of UP after the BJP's sweep in the assembly election. The RSS, the party's mentor, is spreading its wings in the country on the strength of it providing the sinews in the shape of foot soldiers in the mechanics of winning elections. So far, it has planted RSS men first in Haryana and now in Uttarakhand and UP in chief ...
Read More

BJP’s increasing influence

Seema Mustafa
[ March 25, 2017 ]
Today what is absolutely clear is that the Congresss' organisational structure is no match to the BJP-RSS organisational structure. They are able to turn out the vote and pull in the vote much stronger,” former Finance Minister and Congress leader P.Chidambaram just said in Kolkata. What he did not say perhaps directly, but clearly implied, that the Congress is being swallowed up by the BJP in the states, not just where it was in power but...
Read More

Liberals In Shock

Harish Khare
[ March 25, 2017 ]
Most liberals in India are in a state of blue funk. Publicly and privately they bemoan the demonetisation of secular ideas and values after a working mahant from Gorakhpur got anointed as Chief Minister of Uttar Pradesh. There is among the liberals a sense of isolation, even what the French call depaysement. One liberal writes to lament that the new Chief Minister in Manipur is the same person against whom in 2011 the BJP had kicked up a sh...
Read More

Controlling the tongue-Avoid social disease

Dr. Bilal A Bhat
[ March 24, 2017 ]
Almighty Allah had sent Prophets and Messengers from time to time for our guidance. Their mission has always been to reform society, purify it from corrupt practices and set it on a course which Almighty Allah has defined for it. Man’s status as Allah’s vicegerent on earth requires him to follow a certain code of conduct to deserve this title. The last in the chain of Messengers of Allah, our beloved Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) has given us gol...
Read More

Limits Of Modi's Power

Jyoti Malhotra
[ March 23, 2017 ]
Prime Minister Narendra Modi has made his first mistake by helping appoint Yogi Adityanath as Chief Minister of Uttar Pradesh. By installing a man as polarizing and malignant as the five-time MP and head of the Gorakhnath Peeth, Modi has told us that the gloves are off. That, just like Adityanath himself promised, the installation of a Hindu Rashtra has begun. This article isn't about Adityanath. Commentaries and rancorous quotes from Ajay ...
Read More

Electoral coup against a community in UP

Hasan Suroor
[ March 23, 2017 ]

It's official then. Any lingering confusion about the direction of Modi's vision for a new India should be cleared up finally with the coronation of Yogi Adityanath as UP’s Chief Minister after a deeply divisive and exclusionist campaign fronted by the Prime Minister himself. It has been reported that Adityanath was the source of his notorious “Kabristan/Shamshan ghat” line. Recently, a senior journalist asked on Facebook: “How would...
Read More

Now, a Warning from Hindutva Hegemons

S.P.SHUKLA
[ March 22, 2017 ]
Even while politicians and pundits are engaged in analysing the sweeping victory of the BJP at the polls in UP and are still discovering the lessons to be drawn , Hindutva forces have sent a ringing message, a warning, to the entire country. It is not so much what was stated at the elite conclave by the supreme leader. It is not the latest slogan of “New India” laced with the gross rhetoric of everything having gone wrong in the last seven...
Read More

Hindutva as development

Seema Chishti
[ March 22, 2017 ]
With 312 seats for the BJP in the Uttar Pradesh assembly of 403, it is easy to argue that anybody picked to head the state by those MLAs has electoral, and therefore, public legitimacy. But that argument reveals more than it conceals, especially when the BJP fought the UP elections — as it did Bihar in 2015 — on only Narendra Modi’s name, without announcing a chief ministerial candidate. Fully cognisant of the state’s 80 Lok Sabha seats, an...
Read More

Yogic madness

Pratap Bhanu Mehta
[ March 21, 2017 ]
The elevation of Yogi Adityanath as chief minister of Uttar Pradesh is an odious and ominous development. It is an odious choice because the BJP has picked someone who is widely regarded as the single most divisive, abusive, polarising figure in UP politics. He is a politician who has, for most of his political career, been the mascot of militant Hindu sectarianism, reactionary ideas, routinised conflict and thuggery in political discourse,...
Read More

Teachers, teaching and teachers unions

Shabeer Rather
[ March 21, 2017 ]
The common news we read in almost every newspaper and almost every day is like ‘The employees of department X protested under the union Y under the leadership of Mr A to press for their demands'. 'Mr A president of union Y has given ultimatum to the government to full fill their demands'. And all that. Yes! I am talking about trending union culture in Jammu and Kashmir. The general line teachers’ union, ReT teachers’ union, non - gazetted e...
Read More

The two Punjabs

A.G. Noorani
[ March 19, 2017 ]
Last month, the government of Indian Punjab asked the central government to negotiate with Pakistan to allow the transportation of exports through Pakistan’s land routes. It said this would also improve India’s trade with the Commonwealth of States countries. What is far more significant is that Punjab also wants the centre to invite it to future trade meetings with Pakistan. The centre conceded that this issue would be taken up when trade...
Read More

Cong’s poll debacle

S Nihal Singh
[ March 19, 2017 ]
The grim showing of the Congress in the Uttar Pradesh and Uttarakhand Assembly elections has been magnified by the laconic comment of Mr Rahul Gandhi, the torchbearer of the party’s campaign, as a minor dip in its fortunes. Immediately, both the Congress vice-president and other Congress leaders resorted to using medical terminology of surgery, the former on the organisation and the latter on various parts of the party anatomy. The key ques...
Read More

Back to Hindu Paani, Muslim Paani?

Kuldip Nayar
[ March 18, 2017 ]
There was politics even during the period when I was in college before partition. But it was not on communal lines as it is today. Then the enemy was the British and all were at a struggle to oust them. It was in the 40’s when Qaid-e-Azam Mohammad Ali Jinnah came to the Law College at Lahore and exhorted all of us to make a joint effort to drive out the British. Subsequently, things came to such a pass that even water was divided into Hindu...
Read More

Shooting the EVM

S Y Quraishi
[ March 18, 2017 ]
The electronic voting machine (EVM) controversy has raised its head again. Ever since EVMs were introduced in 1982, they have been surrounded by challenges. The Election Commission of India has demonstrated time and again how the system is safe and fool-proof. A combination of safeguards ensures that these machines are fully tamper-proof. Broadly, these can be summed up in four categories: Software and technical, administrative, independent...
Read More

Concept of leadership as defined in Islam

Dr Bilal.A.Bhat
[ March 17, 2017 ]
There was no moral code, no punishment for adultery, nor any moral sanction against it, practically no faith on Allah, life after death, no feeling of responsibility for one’s actions when Prophet Mohammad (S.A.W) was born Mohammad (S.A.W) in the year 570 of the Christian era, in Makka Arab. He (S.A.W) was an orphan from his birth, who lost even his mother when six years old. He came of the noblest family of Arabia, the Quraish, who were ...
Read More

The PM’s gang of four?

Sunil Sharan
[ March 16, 2017 ]
Finally, he’s not leaving Goa. Manohar Parrikar that is. All heave a sigh of relief. The prime minister, the military, everyone, except the Goans. Never in recent memory has a key minister, armed with his IIT armory, promised so much and delivered so little. The PM reportedly wanted to sideline him for quite some time, but the RSS shielded its protectee. Now in his hour of mesmerizing triumph, the PM can do what he wants. Seventy years ago,...
Read More

Fear of Hindu Rashtra

Ajaz Ashraf
[ March 16, 2017 ]
Four months before the Uttar Pradesh election results sent Muslims in India reeling in shock, former Rajya Sabha MP Mohammed Adeeb delivered a speech in Lucknow, which, in hindsight, might be called prescient. “If Muslims don’t wish to have the status of slaves, if they don’t want India to become a Hindu rashtra, they will have to keep away from electoral politics for a while and, instead, concentrate on education,” Adeeb told an audience c...
Read More

Victor and the vanquished

Pratap Bhanu Mehta
[ March 15, 2017 ]
Narendra Modi has scripted another spectacular political triumph. Before the election, there was a lot of hollow speculation; after the election, there will be many post-mortems. But there is no denying one straightforward fact: Modi is an unprecedented phenomenon in the annals of popular politics. He has reduced his competition to minions fighting over scraps. He has weathered every criticism. He has taken every risk and put himself on the...
Read More

Modi real, the wave unreal

Jawed Naqvi
[ March 15, 2017 ]
Punditry notwithstanding, all five Indian states that went to polls recently saw their governments getting evicted. The victims included the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), Congress and the Uttar Pradesh-based Samajwadi Party. In a direct contest between the BJP and Congress in four of the states, it was two each. The BJP was ousted from Goa, which gives Prime Minister Modi his handpicked defence minister. The BJP and its Akali allies were sh...
Read More

A Hindu vote-bank consecrated

Harish Khare
[ March 14, 2017 ]
A simple question: why did the Modi magic work in the old Uttar Pradesh so gloriously, but failed so conspicuously to cast its charm in Punjab, Goa and Manipur? If the Bharatiya Janata Party is the new pan-India party and if Prime Minister Narendra Modi is the only pan-Indian leader, as was loudly claimed after the civic polls in Maharashtra, then why have the party and the leader failed to click beyond the old UP? The answer is simple: th...
Read More

A new idea of India

Meghnad Desai
[ March 14, 2017 ]
The big story of March 11 is the damage done to local parties across the five states. The Samajwadi Party (SP) and BSP, the two parties which have shared power in Uttar Pradesh for the last two terms, have been humiliated. The BSP has paid a heavy price for playing old-fashioned votebank politics. Akhilesh Yadav took a gamble on combining with the Congress by giving them 105 seats. As I had said here then, the Congress has no base left in U...
Read More

Student politics

A.G. Noorani
[ March 12, 2017 ]
The turmoil in the student world in India since January 2016 provides a grim warning of the dangers posed to democracy when students fall prey to extremist politics and resort to violence to silence dissent. In January last year, Dalit scholar Rohith Vemula committed suicide after he was suspended by the Hyderabad University. Najeeb Ahmed, a student at the Jawaharlal Nehru University, disappeared after clashes with persons from the Akhil B...
Read More

Big political test Modi passes

Dinesh Unnikrishnan
[ March 12, 2017 ]
The big takeaway from the assembly poll outcome in Uttar Pradesh (as the results so far suggest), is that Prime Minister Narendra Modi has cleared his big political test on demonetisation—one of the key factors in this round of polls—in grand style. Not only did the massively disruptive economic policy and opposition’s primary weapon against BJP fail to impact Modi’s charisma among voters in the state, but it even seemed to aid party’s fort...
Read More

Quiet poll strategy of muslims in U

Seema Mustafa